De Gulden Passer. Jaargang 43
(1965)– [tijdschrift] Gulden Passer, De– Auteursrechtelijk beschermd
[pagina 248]
| |||||||||||||||||||
Christopher plantin and the states general: Some new documentsGa naar voetnoot*
| |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 249]
| |||||||||||||||||||
as official publisher to the King. It was necessary to proceed with caution. Three months after the signing of the Pacification of Ghent, Plantin printed his first work for the new powers.Ga naar voetnoot1. In his letters to Philip II's secretary Zayas, however, the printer repeatedly stressed that he was being forced to print anti-Spanish material. In spite of his protestations of loyalty to the King, Plantin received from the rebel regime four titles that raised suspicions in Madrid. He was named printer to the States General in 1578, to the city of Antwerp the following year, to François, Duke of Anjou, in 1582, and to the University of Leiden in 1583. There is evidence in the Correspondance that Plantin requested two of these appointments. In October 1578 his letter to the Antwerp magistrates included a broad hint that he was eager to serve them. ... il supplie treshumblement a Vos dittes Segneuries qu'il leur plaise avoir esgard a la bonne volunté et dessein dudit remonstrant, desireux de leur faire tout humble service....Ga naar voetnoot2. On 17 April 1582 Plantin wrote to the Duke of Anjou this request: .......... Prior to this request Plantin had been named printer to the States General. A document dated 17 May 1578 has always been considered the earliest known announcement of his appointment. | |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 250]
| |||||||||||||||||||
Comme les Estatz generaulx pour le bien et repos de ces pays ont trouvé convenir d'avoir certain imprimeur, pour mectre en lumiere ce que pourra pour l'advenir concerner les affaires desdits pays, pour ce est-il qu'ilz ont accepté en qualité que dessus Mre. Christoffle Plantin demourant en Anvers, a condition que quantesfois se mectra quelque chose en lumiere, ledit Plantin en delibvrera ausdicts Estatz trois cens exemplaires gratuitement, et le surplus a ung liart chascun feuillet compté celluy qui ne sera que commencé pour entier, bien entendu aussy qu'il ne pourra vendre ou distribuer aulcuns exemplaires devant que lesdicts Estatz luy ayent consenty et accordé. Faict en l'assemblee desdicts Estatz generaulx le xviie de may xvclxxviii. Les deputez et commis a la chambre des aydes ont enregistré la presente ordonnance consentans en tant que en eulx est que le contenu d'Icelle soit accompli. Et ont signé cestes en Anvers le xxiiiie de may 1578. Jehan de Tolnare, Jan de Penants Serveels. (Au dos:) 17, May 1578, Signé Houfflin. Although this document contains no reference to a request on Plantin's part, the words ‘ilz ont accepté... Plantin,’ and ‘Acceptation des Estats generaux pour C. Plantin’ imply that he offered his services. Since no definite proof was available, however, Maurits Sabbe asked in 1937: ‘Was this position imposed on him, or did he request it? We do not know. In any case, he accepted it.’Ga naar voetnoot5. Maarten Schneider, in his study of early official printers in The Netherlands, criticized Sabbe for asking the question, calling it an attempt to excuse Plantin's duplicity.Ga naar voetnoot6. A few pages later Schneider | |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 251]
| |||||||||||||||||||
stated that Plantin had offered his services to the rebels, but the author presented no new evidence, quoting only Plantin's request to Anjou.Ga naar voetnoot7. New evidence was near at hand. Schneider consulted the published Resolutiën of the States General edited by N. Japikse, but overlooked some very pertinent information there which would have strengthened his criticism of Maurits Sabbe. In the section entitled ‘Varia, 1578,’ Japikse reported the following transactions between Plantin and the States General.
This record of events is a mine of information untapped by Plantin scholars. From it we learn that - | |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 252]
| |||||||||||||||||||
The above chronology is a guide for interpreting four recently-discovered documents concerning Christopher Plantin and the States General. Two letters written by Plantin to the assembly and two notifications of his appointment as their official printer lay undiscovered in the Archives Générales du Royaume de Belgique and the Museum Plantin-Moretus. The first document is Plantin's initial request for a printing monopoly from the States General.Ga naar voetnoot10. After reminding them of the careful work he had already done for them, he asked that they issue an acte general naming him their only printer, or at least give him the privileges for works he had already printed for them. Plantin's ironic reason for the request was that the edicts of the King forbade all printers to issue anything without official permission. The letter is not dated, but the date written in the margin by a secretary of the States agrees with the date given in the Resolutiën - 27 April 1578. The reply from the States General was not slow in coming. According to the first marginal note, on 27 April the States delegated the Pensionary of MechlinGa naar voetnoot11. to present Plantin's request to Matthew, Archduke of Austria and governor of the rebellious Low Countries. On 29 April a secretary wrote a second marginal note on Plantin's letter; Matthew had granted Plantin the right to print all the ma- | |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 253]
| |||||||||||||||||||
terial for the States General. His privilege was to last three years, with the understanding that before publishing, he would show the proofs to the Council of State. A summary of the privilege appeared in most of Plantin's publications for the States General in 1578, 1579, and 1580. Sommaire du Privilege This summary refers to the acte original drawn up by Matthew and his Council of State, which in 1578 was a branch of the States General assisting the governor. A rough draft of this act is in the same portfolio that contains Plantin's petition.Ga naar voetnoot13. His Highness, in the name of the King - the States had not yet officially renounced their allegiance to Philip - gave Plantin permission to print ‘tous livres, placcartz, ordonnances et autres chose que luy seront ordonnees par lesdicts Estatz generaulx.’ For the next three years, other publishers were forbidden to print or counterfeit any official publications for the States General. Something about his appointment left Plantin dissatisfied, for on | |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 254]
| |||||||||||||||||||
12 May he sent a second petition to the States General. Perhaps he wanted more details, or protested against instructions of which there is no record. In any event, the States considered it necessary to send him a supplement to the acte original. Dated 17 May 1578, the supplement contains stipulations made by the Chamber of Appeals concerning free copies for the States, price of remaining copies, and censorship.Ga naar voetnoot14. There is a record in the Resolutiën of two more petitions sent by Plantin to the States General in 1578. Japikse believed that the petition received on 19 September was an undated letter that he found in the Archives Générales in Brussels and reproduced in his publication.Ga naar voetnoot15. It is a request for payment of 312 florins, 18 stuivers, for the printing of Listes des moyens generaulx and other placards. The rough draft of this request, however, is in the Museum Plantin-Moretus and is dated 10 October 1578.Ga naar voetnoot16. Therefore it could not have been the petition received on 19 September of that year. Schneider's explanation of this discrepancy is unsatisfactory. He assigned the letter reproduced in the Resolutiën the date 19 September 1579, calling it a second request, identical to the one written on 10 October 1578.Ga naar voetnoot17. This explanation cannot stand since the letter reproduced in the Resolutiën has a marginal note dated 11 October 1578. The two documents are a rough draft and final copy of one and the same letter, sent on 10 October 1578. Plantin's petition received by the States General on 19 September 1578 was probably a letter requesting payment of 173 florins, 14 stuivers, for the printing of some unnamed ‘livrets et placats.’ The rough draft of this letter is in the Museum Plantin-Moretus.Ga naar voetnoot18. An unrelated letter on the opposite side of the sheet is dated 13 September 1578, reason enough to believe that the letter in question was written on the same day, or at least prior to 19 September. This letter of request for payment is worded so much like the one | |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 255]
| |||||||||||||||||||
dated 10 October 1578, that the editor of the Correspondance believe them to be identical and reproduced only the latter.Ga naar voetnoot19. There is no record in the Resolutiën that Plantin was paid the sum of 173 florins, 14 stuivers. This sum was probably included in the 312 florins, 18 stuivers that he requested on 10 October 1578. On 25 October Matthias Laurin, treasurer of the States General, was instructed to pay Plantin the larger sum. The petition received by the States on 29 October 1578 was most likely another request for payment, for on 20 December of that year the treasurer was instructed to pay Plantin 237 florins, 2 stuivers. Plantin's three-year privilege expired in April 1581, and there is no record of a renewal until later that year. At least two printers took advantage of this situation and published placards for the States General during the summer of 1581. The Museum Plantin-Moretus owns several pamphlets with titles beginning Placcaet vande Staten Generael.... printed in July 1581 by Charles Silvius of Leiden and Cornelis de Rekenare of Ghent. One of these publications is the famous Placard of Dismissal in which Philip II was deposed from dominion over his provinces in the Low Countries. The edition issued by Silvius has these words on the title page: ‘Met privilegie voor twee iaren;’ no summary of a privilege from the States is included, however. In Plantin's publication of this placard there is no trace of a privilege, only the words ‘door 't bevel vande Staten’ - by command of the States - whereas on other placards printed at this time he still calls himself printer to the States General. Plantin evidently did not wish to claim any privilege for the Placard of Dismissal, a damaging publication for anyone who wanted to maintain good relations with the King. In August 1581 the States General adjourned for the year, and the government was in the hands of the Landraad, a Council of State which met in Ghent. One of their first transactions was to reappoint Plantin as official printer. A summary of his privilege is | |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 256]
| |||||||||||||||||||
found in the booklet describing the attempted assassination of the Prince of Orange. Sommaire du PrivilegeGa naar voetnoot20. For a second time Plantin was named exclusive printer of all material the States might need. In the above summary, however, there is no clause as to the length of the agreement. Plantin understandably omitted this stipulation when drawing up the summary, since his second privilege was for only one year. We learn this from the acte original conserved in the Museum Plantin-Moretus.Ga naar voetnoot22. In this document are several new details concerning the printer's relationships with the legislative assembly. | |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 257]
| |||||||||||||||||||
It is unlikely that Plantin received a third appointment as official printer to the States General, since there is no record of his having published for the assembly in 1583. This was a year of great unrest. Anjou's treachery and the advance of Spanish troops caused the Prince of Orange and the center of power to withdraw from Antwerp to Middelburg and thence to various cities in Holland. Plantin himself was inclining northward; he established a printing house in Leiden in 1583 where he began publishing books for the University. Here he also printed for the States General, but on different terms than before; the privilege in a pamphlet dated 17 March 1584 is for that publication only and claims none of the rights of 1578 or 1581. | |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 258]
| |||||||||||||||||||
D'extract vande PrivilegieGa naar voetnoot25. On 22 June 1584 Plantin received another privilege from the States, which has been summarized by Japikse in the Resolutiën. 22 Juni - Gheaccordeert Christoffel Plantin, hooftdrucker deser Nederlanden, octroy in forma, ghelijck hem verghunt is by den Coninck in den cancelrye van Brabant in date den 15 Meerte 1563 voor ses jaeren naer impressie van elcke editie, prout latius in literis.Ga naar voetnoot27. This is not a reappointment as official printer, but merely a six-year copyright for each book he might choose to publish. There was little advantage in printing for the States at that time, for the cause of independence seemed almost lost. Members were deserting the States for Spain, and Philip II's troops were advancing to the very walls of Antwerp. Prior to the siege of Antwerp, Plantin's presses in that city issued placards presenting the decrees made by the States in Delft, but it is doubtful that these had more than a local distribution. The privileges found in earlier placards are not present, only an ominous phrase on the title page, ‘Deur bevel vande Overheyt’ - by command of the authorities. Since Plantin had twdee solicited these | |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 259]
| |||||||||||||||||||
authorities for a printing monopoly, it is difficult to believe that they now were forcing him to print their placards, even though the printer insisted that this is what happened.Ga naar voetnoot28. It is more likely that he had his eye on the balance of power, which in 1584 was tipping in favor of Spain. The following year it was expedient for Plantin (to use his own words) to ‘trim his sails’ once again. Antwerp capitulated in August 1585. A few months later Plantin returned to Antwerp to resume his printing activities there. In 1586, after a lapse of six years, his title pages once again name him ‘imprimeur du Roy.’ | |||||||||||||||||||
ConclusionThe answer to the question Maurits Sabbe asked in 1937 is that Plantin did indeed request the privilege granted him by the States General in 1578. He lost no time in soliciting the favor of the rebellious legislators; his first letter of application was written soon after their removal from Brussels to Antwerp, and the States immediately appointed him their official printer. Neither Sabbe nor his critic Schneider suspected that there was a sequel to the 1578 appointment. Plantin jealously guarded his rights as official printer, and requested a renewal in 1581. His second privilege was for only one year, and after it expired, Plantin's printing activity for the States diminished. In 1584 the States granted him a six-year protection for each of his publications. It proved a rather useless favor, because the following year Plantin returned to the side of Spain. This essay in no way purports to be an exhaustive study on the subject of Christopher Plantin and his relationships with the States General. Such an undertaking should include publication of the pertinent archival material referred to by Japikse in the Resolutiën, plus a search for missing links in the chain of documents, such as Plantin's remonstrantie that prompted the act of 17 May 1578, and his letter requesting the second privilege. The documents reproduced below, however, are enough to give a clear picture of Plantin's | |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 260]
| |||||||||||||||||||
role as printer in the rebellion against Spain. This phase of Plantin's career, usually told in a few sentences, is in reality rich in details that give new nuances of meaning to the words so often used to describe the Antwerp printer - a capitalistic genius. | |||||||||||||||||||
Document I
| |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 261]
| |||||||||||||||||||
[Marginal notes:] Touchant le premier. Le pensionnaire de MalinesGa naar voetnoot32. est par les estatz generaulx depute pour le remonstrer à son Alteze affin que le suppl[ian]t puisse obtenir sa demande et quant a la requeste. Le r[en]voyent au magistrat et coulonelz de ceste ville faict en l'assemblee desd[ict]s estatz le xxvij d Apvril 1578. A. BlylevenGa naar voetnoot33.
Son alteze accord au[dict] suppliant lacte de pouvoir seul avec exclusion d aultres imprimer toutes choses qui luy seront ordonnees par les estatz generaulx pour le terme de trois ans a paine de confiscation des livres par aultre imprimes et peines arbitraires, bien entendu que le suppliant sera tenu a tout communiquer a son Alteze et c[on]seil devant imprimer. Faict en Anvers le 29 dapvril l'an 1578. N. SilleGa naar voetnoot34.
Source: Brussels, Archives Générales du Royaume, Papiers d'état et de l'audience, No. 16903, ‘Correspondance arts, sciences, et lettres.’Ga naar voetnoot35. | |||||||||||||||||||
Document II
| |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 262]
| |||||||||||||||||||
et terme de trois ans prochaine[ment] venans Sans pour ce aucunement faire contre les placcartz et ordonnances de sa Majeste. Interdisans tous autres imprimeurs et libraires pour le temps et termes de trois ans de pouvoir imprimes ou contrefaire les livres, placcarts et aulcuns autres choses venants dela part desdicts Estatz generaulz, a paine de confiscation d'icelles, par aultres imprimez, et pardessus ce de peine arbitraire. Bien entendu que ledict suppliant sera tenu avant povoir imprimer quelque chose le monstrer au conseil d estat estant estant [sic] leu par S[on] Alteze pour le communiquer à Sa Majeste. Fait en Anvers soubs le nom de son Alteze le xxix jour d avril 1578.
Source: Brussels, Archives Générales du Royaume, Papiers d'état et de l'audience, No. 16903, ‘Correspondance arts, sciences, et lettres.’ I wish to thank Mlle. Lucienne van Meerbeeck of the Archives Générales du Royaume for her help in the transcription of this and the above document. | |||||||||||||||||||
Document III
| |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 263]
| |||||||||||||||||||
Document IV
| |||||||||||||||||||
[pagina 264]
| |||||||||||||||||||
exemplaires, et s'il en fault d'advantaige pour les envoyer aux Consaulx provinciaulx a l'accoustume leur sera tenu delivrer moyennant payant ung liart pour ch[ac]un feuillet. Et que led[ic]t suppl[ian]t ne pourra vendre ou distribuer aulcuns desd[ict]s placcartz, Statutz ou ordonnances devant qu'ilz en soyent deubement publiez par cry publicq a l'accoustume, ny a plus hault pris vendre le feuillet d'icelles que au pris ordinaire des aultres libvres par luy ou aultres en Anvers imprimees, a paine de perdre l'effect de cestuy n[ost]re Octroy. Si donnons en mandement a noz treschiers et bien amez le Chancellier et gens du Conseil en Brabant, Marcgrave et Escoutette d'anvers et tous aultres Justiciers et Officiers qui ce appartiendra que de la p[rese]nte grace, conge, Licence, octroy, accord et deffence, et de tout le contenu en cestes, durant le temps selon et par la maniere que dict est, ilz souffrent, facent et laissent led[ic]t suppl[ian]t plainement et paisiblem[ent] ioye et usez, sans luy faire, mectre, ou donner ne souffrir estre faict mis ou donne aulcun destourbier ou empeschement au contraire/ Puis qu'avons ainsy par deliberation de conseil trouve convenir. En tesmoing dequoy avons faict mectre le seel des Estatz de Brabant a ces p[rese]ntes pour n'avoir aultre a la main. Donne en la ville de Gand le troisiesme jour de Septembre, L'an de n[ostr]e Seigneur xvc quatre vingt et ung.
[On the reverse side:] Par ordon[n]an[ce] de mesd [ict]s Seig [neu] rs Les Estatz g[ene]raulx au Conseil d'Estat par eux establi. J. van AsseliersGa naar voetnoot36.
Source: Antwerp, Museum Plantin-Moretus, Archive 1179, Privilege 210. Dr. Leon Voet, curator of the Plantin Museum, kindly showed me where to find this document and helped me with its transcription. |
|